Flagged Goods

Updated 22 November 2026, 04:27 UTC · newest alert 20 November 2026 · 22,016 EU alerts since Dec 2019 · 2,347 US recalls since 2020

Product type

Perfume and eau de toilette: recalls and official safety alerts

Buying or selling perfume and eau de toilette? Get an email when new official alerts come in.

37 new official alerts matched perfume and eau de toilette in the last 4 weeks.

One email a week when new official alerts match perfume and eau de toilette. Unsubscribe any time.

Download these 100 alerts (CSV) English column names; reuse with attribution to the official sources.

DateProductPlatformNotice
2025-01-07 Eau de toiletteMiss 22Brand: Arcobaleno parfumes · barcode 8051773070501 · batch 23/1033 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00030/25
2025-01-07 Eau de toiletteRob 63Brand: Arcobaleno parfumes · barcode 8051773070501 · batch 23/0803 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00080/25
2025-01-07 Eau de toiletteNero 65Brand: Arcobaleno parfumes · barcode 8051773070501 · batch 22/0585 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00081/25
2025-01-07 Eau de toiletteMadame 37Brand: Arcobaleno parfumes · barcode 8051773070501 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00067/25
2025-01-07 Eau de toiletten° 86Brand: DolciSguardi profumi · barcode 8029087006134 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00045/25
2025-01-07 Eau de toiletteSara 30Brand: Arcobaleno parfumes · barcode 8051773070501 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00035/25
2025-01-07 Eau de toiletteKaracter 25Brand: Arcobaleno parfumes · barcode 8051773070501 · batch 23/1285 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00032/25
2025-01-07 Eau de toiletteOpposite 04Brand: Arcobaleno parfumes · barcode 8051773070501 · batch 23/1243 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00048/25
2025-01-07 Eau de toiletteScottish 17Brand: Arcobaleno parfumes · barcode 8051773070150 · batch 007 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00059/25
2025-01-07 Eau de toiletteKen TenBrand: Arcobaleno parfumes · barcode 8051773075001 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00040/25
2025-01-07 Eau de toiletteMercury 29Brand: Arcobaleno parfumes · barcode 8051773070501 · batch 23/0776 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00063/25
2025-01-07 Eau de toiletten° 81Brand: DolciSguardi profumi · barcode 8029087006080 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00066/25
2025-01-07 Eau de toiletteLotus Brand: Kokeshi · model 4331js · barcode 3760048936477 · batch 16I250A Cosmetics · Chemical · France · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00047/25
2025-01-07 PerfumeAromatics in BlackBrand: Clinique · barcode 020714805814 Cosmetics · Chemical · Switzerland · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00043/25
2025-01-07 Eau de toiletten° 69Brand: DolciSguardi profumi · barcode 8029087005991 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00036/25
2025-01-07 Eau de toiletten° 64Brand: DolciSguardi profumi · barcode 8029087005984 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00065/25
2025-01-07 Eau de toiletten° 62Brand: DolciSguardi profumi · barcode 8029087005977 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00034/25
2025-01-07 PerfumeBrand: Creation · model 3556 · barcode 8692229063168 Cosmetics · Chemical · Türkiye · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00031/25
2025-01-07 Eau de toiletten° 58Brand: DolciSguardi profumi · barcode 8029087005946 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00033/25
2025-01-07 PerfumeSolo Soprani - Dream Brand: Luciano Soprani · barcode 767418215036 · batch 92700 - 1503 Cosmetics · Chemical · San Marino · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00024/25
2025-01-07 Eau de toiletten° 57Brand: DolciSguardi profumi · barcode 8029087005939 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00029/25
2025-01-07 Eau de toiletten° 53Brand: DolciSguardi profumi · barcode 8029087005908 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00038/25
2025-01-07 AftershaveRockfordBrand: Eurocosmesi · barcode 088551700051 · batch 925602 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00084/25
2025-01-07 Perfume17 HerBrand: Setablu · barcode 8055348167337 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00064/25
2025-01-07 Eau de toiletten° 52Brand: DolciSguardi profumi · barcode 802987005892 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00041/25
2025-01-07 Eau de toiletten° 40Brand: DolciSguardi profumi · barcode 8029087005847 Cosmetics · Chemical · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00083/25
2025-01-07 Eau de toiletteHommeBrand: Iceberg · model 7141907 · barcode 8002135146228 · batch 10290369 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00026/25
2025-01-06 PerfumeBlack Boise PremiumBrand: Creation · barcode 8692229021069 Cosmetics · Chemical · Türkiye · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00020/25
2025-01-06 Perfume23 HimBrand: Setablu · barcode 8055348167092 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00008/25
2025-01-06 Eau de toiletteFlòBrand: Comin parfum · barcode 8004830281525 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00012/25
2025-01-06 Eau de toiletteMariamaBrand: Comin parfum · barcode 800483298240 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00010/25
2025-01-06 Eau de toiletteEu lùBrand: Comin parfum · barcode 8004830296055 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00014/25
2025-01-06 Eau de toiletteAngelicaBrand: Comin parfum · barcode 8004830281662 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00009/25
2025-01-06 Perfumen°44Brand: DolciSguardi profumi · barcode 8029087009258 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/00006/25
2024-12-20 Perfume08 Brand: Setablu · barcode 8055348167245 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/03834/24
2024-12-20 Eau de parfum09 Brand: Setablu · barcode 8055348167252 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/03832/24
2024-12-19 PerfumeNo: 3519Brand: Creation · barcode 8692229004772 Cosmetics · Chemical · Türkiye · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/03793/24
2024-12-19 Eau de toiletteSS Sergio SoldanoBrand: Sergio Soldano · model Ref 530 · barcode 8050513385301 · batch 109015 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/03814/24
2024-12-19 PerfumeCreation N.2680Brand: Creation · barcode 8692229003355 Cosmetics · Chemical · Türkiye · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/03819/24
2024-12-19 PerfumeSolo Soprani Natural ScientBrand: Luciano Soprani · model LS01464 · barcode 767418214640 · batch 021803 Cosmetics · Chemical · San Marino · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/03818/24
2024-12-19 Perfume30 HimBrand: Setablu · barcode 8055348167160 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/03799/24
2024-12-19 Perfume02 HerBrand: Setablu · barcode 8055348167184 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/03800/24
2024-12-19 Perfume05 HerBrand: Setablu · barcode 8055348167214 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/03801/24
2024-12-19 Perfume11 HerBrand: Setablu · barcode 8055348167276 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/03829/24
2024-12-19 Perfume12 HerBrand: Setablu · barcode 8055348167283 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/03815/24
2024-12-19 Eau de toilette14 HerBrand: Setablu · barcode 8055348167306 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/03788/24
2024-12-19 Perfume16 HerBrand: Setablu · barcode 8055348167320 Cosmetics · Chemical · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/03785/24
2024-12-19 Eau de toiletten° 50Brand: DolciSguardi profumi · barcode 8029087005878 · batch CMP01M21F Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/03798/24
2024-12-19 Eau de toiletteL'Eau CoutureBrand: ELIE SAAB · barcode 3423473985259 · batch REF 3985250 Cosmetics · Chemical · France · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/03786/24
2024-12-18 Perfume2342Brand: Creation · barcode 8692229003195 Cosmetics · Chemical · Türkiye · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/03777/24
2024-12-18 Perfume3511Brand: Creation · barcode 8692229002082 Cosmetics · Chemical · Türkiye · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/03775/24
2024-12-18 Perfume29 HimBrand: Setablu · barcode 8055348167153 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/03767/24
2024-12-18 Eau de toiletteTo beBrand: Police · barcode 679602609364 · batch 1991270A Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03576/24
2024-12-17 PerfumeNO:2563Brand: Creation · barcode 8692229062376 Cosmetics · Chemical · Türkiye · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/03737/24
2024-12-17 PerfumeNo: 2445Brand: Creation · barcode 8692229063328 Cosmetics · Chemical · Türkiye · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/03755/24
2024-12-17 PerfumeNo: 2661Brand: Creation · barcode 8692229004567 Cosmetics · Chemical · Türkiye · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/03759/24
2024-12-17 Eau de toiletteDorineBrand: Comin parfum · barcode 8004830160325 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/03764/24
2024-12-17 PerfumeFemmeBrand: Gian Marco Venturi · barcode 8002747054263 · batch C17255 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered SR/03724/24
2024-12-12 PerfumeAdmitBrand: Creation lamis · barcode 5414666002738 · batch 246666 Cosmetics · Chemical · Belgium · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03604/24
2024-12-12 PerfumeMoon LightBrand: Creation lamis · barcode 6291012871090 · batch 97713 Cosmetics · Chemical · United Arab Emirates · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03683/24
2024-12-12 Eau de toiletteSolo SopraniBrand: Luciano Soprani · barcode 767418214640 · batch 8302 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03547/24
2024-12-12 Eau de toilette setLe Nouvel hommeBrand: Enrico Coveri · barcode 3509161106974 · batch F28096974 Cosmetics · Chemical · France · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03522/24
2024-12-12 Eau de toilette setPure LuckBrand: Linn Young · barcode 8715658390398 · batch B18211 Cosmetics · Chemical · Netherlands · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03557/24
2024-12-12 Eau de toiletteFine Gold 999.9Brand: REAL TIME · barcode 8715658350293 · batch B16217 Cosmetics · Chemical · Netherlands · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03555/24
2024-12-12 Eau de toiletteAuroraBrand: First American Brands, inc New York · model 2528 · barcode 8027669025283 · batch 2822H3 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03544/24
2024-12-12 Eau de toiletteSofia The FirstBrand: Lorenay · barcode 8412428017522 · batch 495 Cosmetics · Chemical · Spain · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03559/24
2024-12-12 Eau de CologneMasha and the bearBrand: Air Val · barcode 663350065657 · batch 5527E310 Cosmetics · Chemical · Spain · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03550/24
2024-12-12 Eau de toiletten°38Brand: DolciSguardi profumi · barcode 8029087005830 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03536/24
2024-12-12 Perfumen°33Brand: DolciSguardi profumi · barcode 8029087009241 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03534/24
2024-12-12 Perfumen° 36Brand: DolciSguardi profumi · barcode 8029087005816 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03549/24
2024-12-12 Eau de toiletten° 32Brand: DolciSguardi profumi Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03553/24
2024-12-12 Eau de toiletten° 17Brand: DolciSguardi profumi · barcode 8029087005700 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03554/24
2024-12-12 Eau de toiletten° 14 · barcode 8029087005670 · batch CMP19Q18 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03551/24
2024-12-12 Eau de toiletten° 13Brand: DolciSguardi profumi · barcode 8029087005663 Cosmetics · Chemical · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03518/24
2024-12-12 Eau de toiletten°11Brand: DolciSguardi profumi · barcode 8029087005649 Cosmetics · Chemical · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03516/24
2024-12-12 Eau de toiletten°12Brand: DolciSguardi profumi · barcode 8029087005656 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03535/24
2024-12-12 Eau de toiletteNew Brand Volcano Cosmetics · Chemical · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03520/24
2024-12-12 Eau de toiletteEliLùBrand: Comin parfum Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03552/24
2024-12-12 Eau de toiletteEau MagicBrand: New Brand · batch A5567 Cosmetics · Chemical · France · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03542/24
2024-12-12 Eau de toiletteElegance New Brand · batch A5683 Cosmetics · Chemical · France · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03541/24
2024-12-12 Eau de toiletteThe RoyalBrand: New Brand Perfumes Cosmetics · Chemical · France · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03540/24
2024-12-12 Eau de toiletteGolf blueBrand: New Brand Perfumes · batch A6733 Cosmetics · Chemical · France · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03543/24
2024-12-12 PerfumeWater Blue ParisBrand: New Brand Perfumes Cosmetics · Chemical · France · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03538/24
2024-12-12 PerfumeConfidenceBrand: New Brand · batch A5695 Cosmetics · Chemical · France · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03531/24
2024-12-12 PerfumeCool WomanBrand: New Brand Perfumes · batch A5370 Cosmetics · Chemical · France · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03539/24
2024-12-12 Eau de toiletteBrand: Jimmy Choo Man · model CH005A03 · barcode 3386460064132 · batch 08G08F310 Cosmetics · Chemical · France · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03527/24
2024-12-11 Eau de toiletteMasha and the BearBrand: AIR-VAL · barcode 663350065909 Cosmetics · Chemical · Spain · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03575/24
2024-12-11 Eau de toiletteGlamour / FunkyBrand: Monella Vagabonda · barcode 8033020300067, 8033020300074 · batch AV08 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03669/24
2024-12-11 PerfumeOroBrand: Renato Balestra · barcode 8007033910094 · batch 19605 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03675/24
2024-12-11 Eau de toiletteMonta DarkBrand: PARFUMS DE QUALITE · barcode 8053830053069 Cosmetics · Chemical · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03668/24
2024-12-10 Eau de toiletteFiammaBrand: Setablu · barcode 8055348168303 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03609/24
2024-12-10 PerfumeBrand: Genny Caress · model 70401 · barcode 8011889704011 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03629/24
2024-12-10 PerfumeAmethysteBrand: Elementi di Byblos · model 92001973 · barcode 8007033914573 · batch 70213 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03605/24
2024-12-10 Eau de toiletteLe Nouvel HommeBrand: Enrico Coveri · barcode 3509161106974 · batch F28096974 Cosmetics · Chemical · France · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03645/24
2024-12-06 PerfumeGolden waveBrand: Creation lamis · barcode 5414666011471 · batch 128279 Cosmetics · Chemical · Belgium · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03591/24
2024-12-06 Eau de toiletteOro FemmeBrand: Renato Balestra · barcode 8007033910094 · batch 19605 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03585/24
2024-12-06 Perfume and body lotion setOlympeaBrand: Paco Rabanne · model 65144893 · barcode 3349668572540 Cosmetics · Chemical · France · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03592/24
2024-12-06 Eau de toiletteNight BlueBrand: Rockford · model GA8469 · barcode 8007033701746 · batch 616102 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03594/24
2024-12-06 PerfumeFresia di LanzaroteBrand: Perlier · barcode 8009740866442 · batch 935003 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03596/24
2024-12-06 PerfumeGennyBrand: Genny · model 10017491 · barcode 8002135094963 · batch 10277101 Cosmetics · Chemical · Italy · Notified by Italy Why: Ingredient not allowed in cosmeticsSales ban ordered A12/03595/24